Both platforms serve the trading card market, but they're built for different sellers. Here's an honest comparison.
Fees
eBay: 13.25% final value fee + payment processing. SuperCatch: Competitive marketplace fees with no insertion fees. For high-value cards, the fee difference adds up significantly.
Audience
eBay: Massive general audience but buyers expect bargains and cards compete with everything else on the platform. SuperCatch: Dedicated trading card collectors and investors. Buyers come specifically to buy cards, leading to higher conversion rates.
Tools
eBay: Generic listing tools designed for all product categories. SuperCatch: Purpose-built for cards — AI recognition, catalog matching, grading integration, and market price data. List 50+ cards per hour with AI batch import.
Verdict
Use both. List everything on SuperCatch for the dedicated audience and lower fees, and syndicate to eBay for the volume. SuperCatch's multi-platform integration makes this seamless.