
Todd Lyght
1991 • Score
Supplemental • #90T

John Kasay's 1991 Score Supplemental rookie card (#96T) captures the Seattle Seahawks kicker at the start of his NFL career during the early '90s trading card boom.
1991 • Score • Supplemental
National Football League • Seattle Seahawks
Near Mint
96T
New
Shipping Calculated at Checkout
The 1991 Score Supplemental set represents a pivotal moment in football card collecting, released during the height of the modern sports card era. This John Kasay #96T rookie card documents the beginning of one of the NFL's most durable kickers, who would go on to become a cornerstone of the Seattle Seahawks franchise. Score's Supplemental series filled gaps in the primary 1991 release, making these cards harder to locate than standard base issues. The card features the clean design language typical of early '90s Score football cards—bold team colors, clear photography, and straightforward typography that defined the era. For collectors building 1991 Score football sets, this Kasay rookie is an essential piece. Kicker cards from this period are often overlooked compared to skill position players, making them accessible entry points for set builders and affordable investments for those seeking complete runs. Whether you're assembling a Seahawks collection, pursuing a 1991 Score football set, or collecting notable NFL kickers, this card bridges nostalgia and practical collecting value.
Last Listing Activity 10 hours agoCreate a listing from this sports-card catalog entry and use the same product details as a starting point.
See how many public collections currently include this card.
0 collectors have this card
The catalog profile below summarizes the card identity, featured subject, and notable collectible traits.
The core identity of the card within the set.
The player, team, league, and sport context tied to this card.
Production details and format-specific attributes.
Material
Card Stock
Language
English
Notable collectible traits associated with this card profile.
The 1991 Score Supplemental John Kasay rookie card occupies a niche tier within the kicker market, a position that historically trades at a discount relative to skill position players but holds steady among specialist collectors. With only one active listing currently available, the market is extremely thin, meaning price discovery is difficult and any transaction could skew perceived value significantly. Kasay's long and decorated NFL career — including his Super Bowl appearance with the Carolina Panthers and his record-setting field goal consistency — lends this card more relevance than a typical late-era kicker rookie.
The 1991 Score Supplemental set was produced in notably lower quantities than Score's base issue, as it was distributed through hobby channels rather than mass retail, giving it a natural print run advantage over standard base cards. This supplemental format inherently limits raw supply, though graded population reports for this specific card remain sparse, suggesting few collectors have submitted it for professional grading. As a result, high-grade copies — PSA 9 or BGS 9.5 — would represent a very small population, which commands a premium in a thin market.
Kasay's retirement status and his legacy as one of the most accurate kickers in NFL history provide a stable, if modest, collector base that is unlikely to erode significantly. The kicker position remains undervalued in the hobby broadly, but sustained interest from set and team collectors keeps demand from disappearing entirely. Grading submission trends for early 1990s Score Supplemental cards are low overall, meaning a high-grade example could see upward momentum if Kasay-related interest spikes around Hall of Fame discussion or career retrospectives.

1991 • Score
Supplemental • #90T

1991 • Score
Supplemental • #91T

1991 • Score
Supplemental • #8T

1991 • Score
Supplemental • #97T

1991 • Score
Supplemental • #89T