Skip to main content
ROOKIE
1 / 2
About This Card

Keith Traylor's 1991 Score Supplemental rookie card (#86T) captures his debut as a Denver Broncos player, serving as a foundational piece for NFL history collectors.

Keith Traylor

1991 • Score • Supplemental

National Football League • Denver Broncos


Seller Offer

$3.99

1 available
Raw/Ungraded Market: $1.64
143% above
Updated 6 days ago
Based on Aggregated Price GuideLowest eBay Listing at Last Check: $1.00 · View on eBay
Condition

Near Mint

Card Number

86T


Loading express checkout
Primary Seller

SuperCatch

New

Shipping Calculated at Checkout

Arrives in 6-8 days

Estimated delivery November 19, 2026 - November 21, 2026

30-day Returns

Market & Price History

Prices Captured Nov 7, 2026
  • $1.64
    Source
    Guide Estimate
    Trend
    Price Details
  • $42.00
    Source
    Guide Estimate
    Trend
    Price Details
  • $13.00
    Source
    Guide Estimate
    Trend
    Price Details
  • $32.00
    Source
    Guide Estimate
    Trend
    Price Details
  • $19.00
    Source
    Guide Estimate
    Trend
    Price Details

30-day Price History

Raw / Ungraded

PriceCharting Price Guide · Guide Estimate evidence · captured Nov 7, 2026

History is building. At least two days of matching observations are needed to show a trend.

Each point is the last stored observation that day for this printing, condition, grader, autograph status and source. Gaps mean no observation; guide estimates and asking prices are not completed sales.
Product Overview

Description

Keith Traylor's 1991 Score Supplemental rookie card, numbered 86T, stands as a significant entry for collectors of Denver Broncos history and 1990s football memorabilia. Issued by Score, this card represents Traylor's initial appearance in a major national trading card product, marking the beginning of his professional journey in the NFL. The Supplemental series is particularly notable among vintage hobbyists for its role in completing the broader 1991 Score set, often featuring players who did not receive base card assignments but were still integral to the league's landscape that year. Traylor, a defensive tackle, brought his physical presence to the Broncos during a competitive era of the league. For investors and set builders, this card number is a known requirement to finish the supplemental subset, driving consistent demand from those dedicated to assembling complete runs. The 1991 Score brand remains a staple in the hobby, recognized for its clean design and comprehensive coverage of the NFL roster, making this Traylor rookie a tangible piece of that specific sporting era. Collectors often seek out this card to fill gaps in their Broncos collections or to complete their 1991 Score supplemental inserts. Whether you are focusing on a specific team, a particular year, or the career of a unique NFL player, this product offers a direct connection to the early 1990s football market. The card's status as a rookie release adds a layer of historical value, distinguishing it from later career cards. As the hobby continues to appreciate the 1990s vintage segment, items like the 1991 Score Supplemental Keith Traylor 86T remain relevant for those looking to preserve and invest in authentic sports history.

Last Listing Activity

11/1/26

Seller Action
Have one of these to sell?

We'll pre-fill the product details from this catalog entry, so your listing lands on this exact page. Just add photos of your copy, pick its condition, and set your price.

Product Specs

Card Details

The catalog profile below summarizes the card identity, featured subject, and notable collectible traits.

Catalog Profile

The core identity of the card within the set.

Year

1991

Brand

Score

Series

Supplemental

Card Number

#86T

Featured Subject

The subject, team, league, and sport context tied to this card.

Print Details

Production details and format-specific attributes.

Material

Card Stock

Language

English

Collector Highlights

Notable collectible traits associated with this card profile.

Rookie
Available Offers

Available Offer for This Card (1)

Compare prices, grades, photos, and shipping from approved sellers.

Seller

SuperCatch

Verified Seller
Featured Offer

New

Condition

Near Mint

Seller Price

$3.99

Shipping Extra
Arrives in 6-8 days
Estimated delivery November 19, 2026 - November 21, 2026
Collector Ownership

Owned by Collectors

See how many public collections currently include this card.

0 collectors have this card

SuperCatch Expert Analysis
Market Value Insight

Keith Traylor's 1991 Score Supplemental rookie card occupies a modest tier within his overall cardography, reflecting a career that spanned over a decade as a journeyman defensive tackle rather than a marquee star. With only one active listing currently available, market activity is extremely thin, which can create artificial price spikes on isolated sales rather than reflecting true sustained demand. Collectors should weigh this card against the broader 1991 Score Supplemental set, which generally trades at the lower end of the early-90s football card market.

Rarity Breakdown

The 1991 Score Supplemental series was distributed in limited quantities compared to the base Score set, as it was released as an add-on product later in the year, giving it a marginally smaller print run by default. However, this is a standard base card with no serial numbering, parallels, or known short print variations, meaning supply is not dramatically constrained in the way an autograph or numbered parallel would be. Graded population data for this specific card is likely minimal, with most copies remaining in raw, ungraded condition given the player's secondary market status.

Investment Outlook

Traylor had a respectable NFL career as a run-stopping nose tackle, including notable stints with the Chicago Bears and New England Patriots, but he does not carry the Hall of Fame trajectory or cultural cachet that drives sustained rookie card premiums. The single active listing suggests a dormant market with little collector momentum, and grading submission trends for this card are almost certainly negligible. Unless a significant nostalgic or team-collector niche emerges, this card is unlikely to see meaningful appreciation and is best suited for player or team set collectors rather than investment-focused buyers.

AI-Generated Editorial Analysis

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the 1991 Score Supplemental Keith Traylor card a rookie card?

Yes, card #86T from the 1991 Score Supplemental series is widely recognized as Keith Traylor's rookie card in major trading card sets.

What is the significance of the Supplemental series in 1991 Score?

The Supplemental series includes cards for players who were not featured in the base 1991 Score set, making them essential for collectors aiming to complete the full product run.

How does this card fit into Denver Broncos collecting?

This card documents Keith Traylor's tenure with the Broncos, serving as a key piece for collectors focusing on team history or defensive players from the early 1990s.