$1.01Over the last 30 days, stored prices ranged from $1.01 to $1.42 across 3 capture days. Change between Aug 24, 2026 and Sep 9, 2026: -28.9%. Compares the same source, grade and signed status. Capture days are not completed-sale counts.
7
Asking prices
Based on eBay Active Listings
Source observation date unavailable
Price History
Loading price history
Product Overview
Description
The 1996-97 Donruss Sandy McCarthy #42 hockey card captures a specific moment in NHL history, featuring the Calgary Flames defenceman during the late 1990s era. As a standard issue from the Donruss brand, this card represents a fundamental piece of 90s hockey memorabilia for enthusiasts of the league's past. Sandy McCarthy was a notable presence on the Flames' blue line, known for his defensive reliability and physical play. Collectors often seek out this card number to complete their sets of the 1996-97 Donruss hockey release. The card's design reflects the bold, colorful aesthetic that characterized Donruss products during this period, making it a recognizable item for fans of the era. For investors and hobbyists alike, vintage hockey cards from the mid-90s hold a distinct place in the market. The Calgary Flames have a rich history, and McCarthy's tenure adds depth to the franchise's roster records. This card serves as a tangible link to those seasons, allowing collectors to preserve the legacy of players who contributed to the team's identity. Whether you are building a comprehensive collection of Donruss issues or focusing on Calgary Flames history, this card is a relevant addition. The 1996-97 season was a pivotal time for the NHL, and owning a piece of that year helps document the sport's evolution. The appeal of the 1996-97 Donruss Sandy McCarthy #42 card lies in its straightforward representation of a working NHL player. It does not rely on rare parallels or autographs but stands on the merit of being a core component of a popular set. For those who appreciate the straightforward nature of standard issue cards, this piece offers a clear window into the 90s hockey landscape. Collecting vintage sports cards is often about the stories behind the players and the teams. McCarthy's time with the Flames is part of that broader narrative. By acquiring this card, collectors support the preservation of sports history and add a verified piece of NHL heritage to their collection. The enduring popularity of 90s hockey cards ensures that items like this remain sought after by a dedicated community of fans and investors.
Last Listing Activity
5 days ago
Seller Action
Have one of these to sell?
We'll pre-fill the product details from this catalog entry, so your listing lands on this exact page. Just add photos of your copy, pick its condition, and set your price.
Product Specs
Card Details
The catalog profile below summarizes the card identity, featured subject, and notable collectible traits.
See how many public collections currently include this card.
0 collectors have this card
SuperCatch Expert Analysis
Market Value Insight
This card represents a high-volume base issue from the mid-90s hockey market, placing it in the lowest tier of the player's collectible portfolio. As a non-premium Sandy McCarthy card, it trades significantly below the market for any autographed or serial-numbered variations. The current valuation reflects its status as a common entry point rather than a standalone investment piece.
Rarity Breakdown
The item lacks any special scarcity mechanics such as serial numbering, short-print status, or parallel coatings, indicating it is a standard base card. Without limited edition constraints or unique physical attributes, the supply remains effectively unlimited relative to collector demand. This generic classification means it does not benefit from the supply-side premiums seen in parallel or insert sets.
Investment Outlook
As a standard rookie-year card from the 1996-97 Donruss set, it serves primarily as a foundational piece for broad NHL team or player collections. Demand is driven by the need for base cards to complete sets rather than speculative growth, resulting in stable but minimal market movement. Investors should view this as a low-cost acquisition for variety rather than a vehicle for capital appreciation.
