Skip to main content
1 / 2
About This Card

Acquire the 1996 Topps Don Mattingly #185 baseball card, featuring the New York Yankees icon in the iconic mid-90s Topps design.

Don Mattingly

1996 • Topps

Major League Baseball • New York Yankees


Seller Offer

$1.87

1 available
Raw/Ungraded Market: $1.52
23% above
Updated 1 day ago
Based on Aggregated Price GuideLowest eBay Listing at Last Check: $0.99 · View on eBay
Condition

Near Mint

Card Number

185


Loading express checkout
Primary Seller

SuperCatch

New

Shipping Calculated at Checkout

Arrives in 4-6 days

Estimated delivery November 16, 2026 - November 18, 2026

30-day Returns

Market & Price History

Prices Captured Nov 11, 2026 Unless Another Date Is Shown
  • $1.52
    Source
    Guide Estimate
    Trend
    +7.8%
    Price Details
  • $1.50
    Source
    Completed Sales
    Trend
    +3.4%
    Price Details
  • $0.99
    Source
    Guide Estimate
    Trend
    0%
    Price Details
  • $8.19
    Source
    Guide Estimate
    Trend
    -0.5%
    Price Details
  • $19.57
    Source
    Guide Estimate
    Trend
    +15.2%
    Price Details
  • $22.00
    Source
    Guide Estimate
    Trend
    +15.8%
    Price Details
  • $76.00
    Source
    Guide Estimate
    Trend
    -10.6%
    Price Details
  • $17.00
    Source
    Guide Estimate
    Trend
    0%
    Price Details
  • $58.75
    Source
    Guide Estimate
    Trend
    -9.6%
    Price Details
  • $35.00
    Source
    Guide Estimate
    Trend
    -10.3%
    Price Details
Below grade 10 the guide publishes one estimate across all graders, so these rows are not PSA, BGS, CGC or SGC prices, and a low slabbed grade can sit below a clean raw copy. Grade 10 is estimated per grader.

30-day Price History

Raw / Ungraded

PriceCharting Price Guide · Guide Estimate evidence · captured Nov 11, 2026

Each point is the last stored observation that day for this printing, condition, grader, autograph status and source. Gaps mean no observation; guide estimates and asking prices are not completed sales.
Product Overview

Description

The 1996 Topps Don Mattingly #185 stands as a definitive piece of New York Yankees history within the broader sports card market. As a staple of the 1996 Topps baseball set, this card captures the enduring legacy of one of the franchise's most recognizable figures. For collectors focusing on vintage baseball cards, the 1996 Topps Don Mattingly #185 offers a tangible connection to the era when the Yankees remained a dominant force in professional baseball. The card number 185 places it within the standard base set run, making it an accessible yet significant item for those building comprehensive collections. The simplicity of the design allows the image and the player's association with the New York Yankees to take center stage, a hallmark of the Topps brand's approach during this period. Whether you are a dedicated enthusiast of the New York Yankees or simply appreciate the aesthetic of 1990s sports memorabilia, this card serves as a key component for set completion. Adding the 1996 Topps Don Mattingly #185 to your inventory provides a solid foundation for any collection centered on the New York Yankees or the 1996 baseball season. It represents a specific moment in time, preserved in the standardized format that made Topps a household name in sports collecting.

Last Listing Activity

11/1/26

Seller Action
Have one of these to sell?

We'll pre-fill the product details from this catalog entry, so your listing lands on this exact page. Just add photos of your copy, pick its condition, and set your price.

Product Specs

Card Details

The catalog profile below summarizes the card identity, featured subject, and notable collectible traits.

Catalog Profile

The core identity of the card within the set.

Year

1996

Brand

Topps

Card Number

#185

Featured Subject

The subject, team, league, and sport context tied to this card.

Print Details

Production details and format-specific attributes.

Material

Card Stock

Language

English

Available Offers

Available Offer for This Card (1)

Compare prices, grades, photos, and shipping from approved sellers.

Seller

SuperCatch

Verified Seller
Featured Offer

New

Condition

Near Mint

Seller Price

$1.87

Shipping Extra
Arrives in 4-6 days
Estimated delivery November 16, 2026 - November 18, 2026
Collector Ownership

Owned by Collectors

See how many public collections currently include this card.

0 collectors have this card

SuperCatch Expert Analysis
Market Value Insight

As a 1996 Topps base card of Don Mattingly, this item represents a standard entry point for Yankees collectors rather than a high-tier investment piece. While Mattingly remains a significant figure in franchise history, base cards from the mid-90s generally trade at accessible price points unless they feature pristine centering and corners. The scarcity of active listings suggests a thin market, but the card itself lacks the premium attributes required to command prices significantly above its baseline value tier.

Rarity Breakdown

This card is a standard base issue with no noted special attributes such as serial numbering, short printing, or parallel foil treatments. Consequently, its supply is determined solely by the original print run of the 1996 Topps set, which was mass-produced for widespread distribution. Without limited edition markers or unique identifiers, the card relies on condition survival for any relative scarcity, making it a common find among collectors.

Investment Outlook

The investment potential for this specific card is limited due to its status as a non-premium base card from a period known for high production volumes. Demand is primarily driven by casual Yankees memorabilia collectors or those completing specific year-set collections rather than serious investors seeking appreciating assets. Long-term value stability may exist due to Mattingly's legacy, but significant upside is unlikely without exceptional grade or future market shifts toward vintage base sets.

AI-Generated Editorial Analysis

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

What year was the Don Mattingly #185 card released?

The Don Mattingly #185 card was released as part of the 1996 Topps baseball set. This places it firmly in the mid-1990s era of sports card production.

Which team does Don Mattingly represent on this card?

On this card, Don Mattingly is featured as a member of the New York Yankees. The 1996 Topps set highlights his long-standing tenure with the franchise.

Is the 1996 Topps Don Mattingly #185 an autographed card?

No, the 1996 Topps Don Mattingly #185 is a standard base card and does not include an autograph. It features the standard photographic design typical of the set.