Skip to main content
1 / 2
About This Card

The 1997 Pinnacle Score Andy Pettitte #5 baseball card features the New York Yankees pitcher in the iconic score-style design of the era.

Andy Pettitte

1997 • Score

Major League Baseball • New York Yankees


Seller Offer

$2.99

1 available
Active-Listing Market: $1.15
160% above
Updated about 2 hours ago
Based on eBay Active Listings · 14 listings sampledLowest eBay Listing at Last Check: $0.99 · View on eBay
Condition

Near Mint

Card Number

5


Loading express checkout
Primary Seller

SuperCatch

New

Shipping Calculated at Checkout

Arrives in 4-6 days

Estimated delivery November 14, 2026 - November 16, 2026

30-day Returns

Market & Price History

  • $1.15
    Source
    Asking Prices
    Trend
    +15%
    Price Details

30-day Price History

Raw / Ungraded

eBay Active Listings · Asking Prices evidence · captured Nov 10, 2026

Each point is the last stored observation that day for this printing, condition, grader, autograph status and source. Gaps mean no observation; guide estimates and asking prices are not completed sales.
Product Overview

Description

The 1997 Pinnacle Score Andy Pettitte #5 baseball card stands as a notable entry for collectors of New York Yankees memorabilia. Released during the 1997 season, this product captures the pitcher's presence within one of the most recognizable designs in sports card history. The Pinnacle Score brand is renowned for its clean, classic aesthetic, making cards from this year highly sought after by enthusiasts who appreciate the era's distinct visual style. Andy Pettitte was a cornerstone of the Yankees' rotation during this period. As card number 5 in the base set, this product holds a prominent position for those building a comprehensive collection of the 1997 Pinnacle Score release. Collecting this card often serves as a stepping stone for those interested in the broader history of the New York Yankees franchise. The 1997 Pinnacle Score set offers a snapshot of the team's roster at a pivotal time, and Pettitte's inclusion is essential for any complete set. Whether you are focusing on individual player cards or the entire brand, the 1997 Pinnacle Score Andy Pettitte #5 card represents a fundamental piece of baseball trading card history. Its enduring popularity ensures that it remains a staple for investors and hobbyists alike who value the structural integrity and historical context of the Score series.

Last Listing Activity

11/1/26

Seller Action
Have one of these to sell?

We'll pre-fill the product details from this catalog entry, so your listing lands on this exact page. Just add photos of your copy, pick its condition, and set your price.

Product Specs

Card Details

The catalog profile below summarizes the card identity, featured subject, and notable collectible traits.

Catalog Profile

The core identity of the card within the set.

Year

1997

Brand

Score

Card Number

#5

Featured Subject

The subject, team, league, and sport context tied to this card.

Print Details

Production details and format-specific attributes.

Material

Card Stock

Language

English

Available Offers

Available Offer for This Card (1)

Compare prices, grades, photos, and shipping from approved sellers.

Seller

SuperCatch

Verified Seller
Featured Offer

New

Condition

Near Mint

Seller Price

$2.99

Shipping Extra
Arrives in 4-6 days
Estimated delivery November 14, 2026 - November 16, 2026
Collector Ownership

Owned by Collectors

See how many public collections currently include this card.

0 collectors have this card

SuperCatch Expert Analysis
Market Value Insight

This 1997 Pinnacle Score base card represents a foundational entry into Andy Pettitte's collecting profile, reflecting his tenure with the New York Yankees during a pivotal era. While it lacks the premium associated with rookie cards or high-grade parallels, its current positioning suggests it trades at a modest tier relative to his more sought-after memorabilia. The availability of only one active listing indicates a thin market, where supply constraints may allow for minor price appreciation despite the base nature of the card.

Rarity Breakdown

As a standard base card within the 1997 Pinnacle Score set, this item carries no inherent scarcity mechanisms such as serial numbering, short-print designations, or parallel variations. Its supply is effectively determined by the original print run of the base set, meaning it is widely available compared to limited-edition inserts. Consequently, the card relies entirely on player demand rather than scarcity-driven value, making it a common component in broader collections.

Investment Outlook

Investment potential is primarily driven by Pettitte's legacy as a key Yankees pitcher rather than the card's intrinsic attributes. Collectors seeking to complete base sets or build affordable portfolios may view this as a stable, low-risk component, though it is unlikely to generate significant capital appreciation on its own. The lack of special attributes limits its appeal to niche investors focusing strictly on the player's career significance during the late 1990s Yankees dynasty.

AI-Generated Editorial Analysis

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the 1997 Pinnacle Score Andy Pettitte card a rookie card?

No, this is not a rookie card. Andy Pettitte made his MLB debut in 1995, so the 1997 Pinnacle Score release is a standard base card from the middle of his career.

What makes the Pinnacle Score set distinctive?

This classic aesthetic has made the 1997 version a favorite among collectors who value the era's straightforward presentation.

Why is card number 5 significant in this set?

Card number 5 places this product early in the base set sequence, often corresponding to a key player or team leader. For Yankees collectors, having the early-numbered cards like #5 is often a priority for completing the full 1997 Pinnacle Score collection.