What are the most valuable baseball trading cards?

Rookie cards of Hall of Famers like Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays, and Ted Williams command premium prices, as do modern rookie cards of players who become superstars. Condition and grading significantly impact value—high-grade examples sell for substantially more than lower grades of the same card.

Which baseball card brands are most collectible?

Topps, Bowman, and Upper Deck are the most historically significant, with Topps dominating the vintage market and Bowman known for prospect cards. Fleer and Donruss also have loyal collectors, particularly for 1980s and 1990s releases that defined the modern hobby.

How do I start a baseball card collection?

Begin by deciding your focus—vintage cards, a specific era, a favorite player, or modern releases. Start with affordable cards to learn grading standards, then gradually invest in higher-grade or rarer specimens as your knowledge grows.

Filters

Price Range

013000

Grader

All CardsUngraded (12640)PSA (191)BGS (2)

Grade

All Grades10 (53)9.5 (2)9 (72)8.5 (1)8 (36)

Condition

All ConditionsNear Mint (12619)Excellent (20)Good (1)

Year

All Years2025 (2)2024 (618)2023 (936)2022 (421)2021 (291)

Brand

All BrandsTopps (8761)Fleer (1433)Upper Deck (979)Bowman (866)Donruss (271)

Set

All Sets (6398)Series 1 (1021)Allen & Ginter (938)Series 2 (864)Traded (457)

Subset

All SubsetsProspects (95)Mini (47)Silver Portrait (21)Warning Track Collection (15)United States (14)

Player

All PlayersJung Hoo Lee (21)Mark Mcgwire (18)Aaron Judge (17)Randy Johnson (17)Dustin Pedroia (17)

Team

All TeamsNew York Yankees (572)Boston Red Sox (506)Chicago Cubs (500)Los Angeles Dodgers (487)St. Louis Cardinals (481)

Sport

All SportsBaseball (12793)Football (5)Basketball (1)

League

All LeaguesMLB (12604)International Baseball (62)NCAA (15)NFL (6)NPB (1)

Card Number

All Card Number1 (18)1t (4)2 (17)2t (4)2b (1)

Rookie Card

All Rookie CardNo (12028)Yes (771)

Autographed

All AutographedNo (12740)Yes (59)

Serial Numbered

All Serial NumberedNo (12724)Yes (75)

Variation/Parallel

All Variation/Parallel (12)150th Anniversary (5)1983 Topps Design (16)1988 Topps Autograph (1)574 (1)

Error Card

All Error CardNo (12799)

Promo

All PromoNo (12799)

Hologram

All HologramNo (12799)

Limited Edition

All Limited EditionNo (12799)

Seller

All SellersSupercatch (12833)

4705Total Players

$0.01Starting Price

12789Total Cards

⚾

Baseball

Explore our extensive baseball trading card collection featuring classic and contemporary releases from the sport's most trusted manufacturers.

12,789 results

Bobby Abreu

2012 • Topps

Heritage High Number • #H669

PSA 9

$249.99

Miguel Andujar

2019 • Topps

Chrome • Pink Refractor • #108

Near Mint

$1.50

David Freese

2009 • Topps

Heritage • #555

Near Mint

$2.99

Alex Cobb

2024 • Topps

Series 2 • #497

Near Mint

$1.99

Jonathan Broxton

2012 • Topps

Heritage • #H598

PSA 9

$399.99

Travis Fryman

1997 • Topps

Finest • #18

Near Mint

$1.50

Christian Yelich

2019 • Topps

Stadium Club • #87

Near Mint

$2.99

Babe Ruth

2022 • Panini

Select • Cosmic • #70

PSA 9

$189.99

Heliot Ramos

2022 • Topps

Allen & Ginter • #209

Near Mint

$1.13

Royce Lewis

2023 • Topps

Big League • #34

Near Mint

$9.99

Wade Boggs

1988 • Donruss

#153

Near Mint

$2.99

Ronny Simon

2023 • Bowman

Chrome • #BCP-112

Near Mint

$4.99

Lorenzo Cain

2018 • Topps

Update • 1983 Topps Design • #83-25

Near Mint

$1.00

Javier Baez

2020 • Panini

Donruss • #90

Near Mint

$1.00

Mike Sirotka

2000 • Fleer

Tradition Glossy • #161

Near Mint

$1.00

Jose Valentin

1999 • Pacific

Paramount • #129

Near Mint

$1.99

Mickey Moniak

2021 • Topps

Allen & Ginter Chrome • Refractor • #213

Near Mint

$1.00

Shane Bieber

2023 • Topps

Series 1 • #298

Near Mint

$3.99

Gary Sanchez

2018 • Topps

Heritage • #NAP-15

Near Mint

$5.99

Danny Santana

2014 • Topps

Heritage High Number • #H586

Near Mint

$3.99

Jarred Kelenic

2021 • Topps

Holiday • #HW86

Near Mint

$2.49

Rock Raines

1990 • Topps

Big • #154

Near Mint

$1.00

Prince Fielder

2012 • Topps

Chrome • #26

Near Mint

$1.99

Leody Taveras

2021 • Topps

Allen & Ginter • #228

Near Mint

$4.99

Otto Lopez

2022 • Topps

Gallery • #41

Near Mint

$4.99

/2019

Greg Allen

2019 • Topps

Series 2 • #514

Near Mint

$4.99

Jeff Bagwell

2001 • Topps

Gallery • #27

Near Mint

$1.99

Bruce Rondon

2013 • Topps

Heritage High Number • #H512

Near Mint

$9.99

James Brown

2012 • Topps

Allen & Ginter • #220

Near Mint

$4.99

Julio Rodriguez

2023 • Topps

Update • #88US-43

Near Mint

$3.99

Show:

of 12,789

Page 35 of 1599/1599