What is Reggie Mcelroy's most valuable card?

Reggie Mcelroy's 1989 Pro-Set rookie card is typically his most sought-after issue, as Pro-Set 1989 cards are foundational vintage football releases and represent the start of his professional career with the Dallas Cowboys.

Did Reggie Mcelroy make the Hall of Fame?

No, Reggie Mcelroy did not make the Pro Football Hall of Fame. He remains a role-player collectible from the late-1980s Cowboys era, appealing primarily to vintage set builders and team collectors rather than hall-of-fame investors.

Why collect Reggie Mcelroy football cards?

Collectors pursue Reggie Mcelroy cards to complete 1989 Pro-Set sets, build vintage Dallas Cowboys team collections, or assemble defensive back lineups from the late 1980s NFL era. His cards offer affordable vintage football card options with solid historical context.

Filters

Price Range

Grader

All Cards

Condition

All ConditionsExcellent (1)

Year

All Years1989 (1)

Brand

All BrandsPro Set (1)

Set

All Sets (1)

Player

All PlayersReggie Mcelroy (1)

Team

All TeamsNew York Jets (1)

Sport

All SportsFootball (1)

League

All LeaguesNFL (1)

Card Number

All Card Number302 (1)

Rookie Card

All Rookie CardNo (1)

Autographed

All AutographedNo (1)

Serial Numbered

All Serial NumberedNo (1)

Error Card

All Error CardNo (1)

Promo

All PromoNo (1)

Hologram

All HologramNo (1)

Limited Edition

All Limited EditionNo (1)

Seller

All SellersSupercatch (1)

0CB

0RC 1988

0Born 1965

1Team

$2.99Starting Price

1Cards

🏆

Reggie Mcelroy Football

Reggie Mcelroy football cards from his 1988–1992 career with the Dallas Cowboys, featuring Pro-Set 1989 issues and other vintage releases for collectors.

Reggie Mcelroy was a cornerback who played for the Dallas Cowboys during the late 1980s and early 1990s, appearing in the NFL from 1988 to 1992.…Read more

His Pro-Set 1989 card remains a key vintage football collectible from that era, capturing Mcelroy during his time in Dallas when the franchise was building toward its dominant 1990s run. As a defensive back, Mcelroy's cards appeal to Cowboys fans, vintage football collectors, and those completing 1989 Pro-Set sets. Reggie Mcelroy cards are moderately sought after among vintage football enthusiasts, particularly his early Pro-Set issues that represent the late-1980s card boom. While Mcelroy did not achieve Hall of Fame status, his cards retain steady collector interest as part of broader Cowboys team collections and vintage NFL card portfolios. Pro-Set releases from 1989 are widely collected for their historical significance and design, making Mcelroy's appearances valuable to set builders. Collectors pursuing complete Cowboys lineups or 1989 Pro-Set runs will find Reggie Mcelroy cards a practical addition to their holdings. The defensive back's cards offer affordable entry points into vintage football card collecting while maintaining relevance within the broader Dallas Cowboys card market.

1 result

Player: Reggie Mcelroy

Reggie McElroy

1989 • Pro Set

#302

Excellent

$2.99