
Todd Stottlemyre
1989 • Fleer
#245
The 1989 Bowman Todd Stottlemyre baseball card, numbered 242, represents a specific entry in the vintage sports trading card market for Toronto Blue Jays collectors.
1989 • Bowman
Major League Baseball • Toronto Blue Jays
Near Mint
242
New
Shipping Calculated at Checkout
The 1989 Bowman Todd Stottlemyre baseball card, numbered 242, serves as a tangible link to the late-1980s era of the Toronto Blue Jays. As a product of the Bowman brand, this card captures a moment in the team's history during a period of significant growth in Major League Baseball. Collectors seeking to build comprehensive sets often look for specific card numbers like 242 to complete their collection without gaps. The Bowman brand was a dominant force in the trading card industry during this time, and its products are frequently studied for their historical significance in the hobby. For investors and hobbyists alike, cards from this year offer a window into the design trends and player rosters of that period. Todd Stottlemyre's association with the Toronto Blue Jays adds a layer of team-specific interest to this card. Whether you are a fan of the franchise or a generalist collector of 1989 baseball issues, this card fits into the narrative of the sport's evolution. The straightforward presentation of the subject allows the card to stand on its own merits as a piece of sports history.
8/8/26
We'll pre-fill the product details from this catalog entry, so your listing lands on this exact page. Just add photos of your copy, pick its condition, and set your price.
The catalog profile below summarizes the card identity, featured subject, and notable collectible traits.
The subject, team, league, and sport context tied to this card.
Production details and format-specific attributes.
Material
Card Stock
Language
English
Compare prices, grades, photos, and shipping from verified sellers
SuperCatch
New
Near Mint
See how many public collections currently include this card.
0 collectors have this card
Todd Stottlemyre's 1989 Bowman rookie-era card occupies the lower end of the value spectrum for late-1980s Bowman pitchers, as the overproduction era of that period suppresses baseline demand across the board. With only one active listing currently available, the market is effectively illiquid, which can create artificial scarcity in the short term but does not reflect strong collector appetite. Stottlemyre's career as a solid mid-rotation starter for the Blue Jays' championship teams of the early 1990s provides modest historical relevance without commanding a meaningful premium.
The 1989 Bowman set was produced in high volume, making this a standard base card with no known short print variations or serialized parallels from this era. Graded population reports for this specific card remain thin, with relatively few PSA or BGS submissions compared to contemporaries from the same set who had longer star-level careers. Raw copies circulate freely in the secondary market, and high-grade examples (PSA 9 or 10) represent the only tier where any meaningful scarcity argument can be made.
Stottlemyre retired without Hall of Fame consideration, which limits the long-term speculative upside typically associated with legacy-driven price appreciation. Grading submission trends for late-1980s Bowman commons have not shown notable momentum, and collector interest remains largely nostalgic rather than investment-driven. The card is best positioned as a low-cost set filler or a targeted pickup for dedicated Blue Jays team collectors rather than a growth-oriented portfolio asset.

1989 • Fleer
#245

2000 • Fleer
Tradition Glossy • #355

1990 • Topps
#591

1992 • Upper Deck
Low Number • #371

1998 • Topps
Series 1 • #139