Source date not availableAsking prices are unsold offers, not completed sales. Repeated observations do not establish additional buyer demand.This estimate is older and may not reflect today's market.
Over the last 30 days, stored prices ranged from $0.99 to $1.00 across 2 capture days. Change between Aug 31, 2026 and Sep 16, 2026: 1%. Compares the same source, grade and signed status. Capture days are not completed-sale counts.
$1.00
Source
Asking Prices
Trend
+1%
Price Details
Based on eBay Active Listings · 22 observations
Estimate: $1.00, based on Asking Prices.
Source date not availableAsking prices are unsold offers, not completed sales. Repeated observations do not establish additional buyer demand.This estimate is older and may not reflect today's market.
Over the last 30 days, stored prices ranged from $0.99 to $1.00 across 2 capture days. Change between Aug 31, 2026 and Sep 16, 2026: 1%. Compares the same source, grade and signed status. Capture days are not completed-sale counts.
Each point is the last stored observation that day for this printing, condition, grader, autograph status and source. Gaps mean no observation; guide estimates and asking prices are not completed sales.
Product Overview
Description
The 1991 Fleer Todd Stottlemyre #186 card stands as a definitive piece of early 1990s baseball memorabilia. Released by Fleer, this product captures a specific moment in the career of the Toronto Blue Jays pitcher. For collectors of vintage sports cards, this release represents a tangible connection to the era when Fleer redefined the design language of trading cards. The card is numbered 186 within the base set, placing it firmly in the mid-range of the collection.
Todd Stottlemyre’s inclusion in this 1991 release is significant for fans of the Toronto Blue Jays. While the card itself does not mark his rookie debut, it documents his presence during a pivotal time in franchise history. The base card format is widely recognized for its distinct border and photographic style, which has become synonymous with the brand’s identity from that period. Collectors often seek out these cards to complete their 1991 Fleer sets or to build specialized collections focused on specific players or teams.
Investing in this card allows enthusiasts to own a piece of baseball history that remains relevant in the secondary market. This card, featuring Stottlemyre, offers a straightforward yet valuable addition to any portfolio. Whether you are hunting for a specific player to round out a team set or looking to add a reliable piece from the Fleer catalog, this card delivers on collector expectations. The enduring appeal of 1990s baseball cards ensures that items like the 1991 Fleer Todd Stottlemyre #186 remain in demand among those who appreciate the sport’s rich heritage.
Last Listing Activity
9/17/26
Seller Action
Have one of these to sell?
We'll pre-fill the product details from this catalog entry, so your listing lands on this exact page. Just add photos of your copy, pick its condition, and set your price.
Product Specs
Card Details
The catalog profile below summarizes the card identity, featured subject, and notable collectible traits.
See how many public collections currently include this card.
0 collectors have this card
SuperCatch Expert Analysis
Market Value Insight
This 1991 Fleer base card of Todd Stottlemyre sits at the entry-level price tier, reflecting its status as a common issue from a high-volume set. While it captures a key moment with the Toronto Blue Jays, the lack of special parallels or variations keeps its value modest compared to his more sought-after rookie or specialty cards. The current market position indicates steady, low-level liquidity rather than significant appreciation potential for this specific iteration.
Rarity Breakdown
As a standard base card with no noted parallels, short prints, or serial numbering, this item represents the highest supply tier within the 1991 Fleer set. The absence of any scarcity mechanics means it is not constrained by limited production runs or unique attributes that typically drive collector competition. Its ubiquity ensures widespread availability, which inherently caps its rarity-driven premium potential.
Investment Outlook
Investment prospects are limited by the card's position as a non-rookie, base-issue item from a mass-produced series. Demand is primarily driven by general set completionists rather than specific player accolades or card scarcity features. Long-term value retention relies on the broader nostalgia for 1990s baseball cards, but this specific card lacks the unique hooks needed for substantial market growth.
