Painful Quandary is a rare enchantment from Magic: The Gathering's 2022 Brothers' War expansion, designed to tax opponents' resources while preserving your own.
Painful Quandary
2022 • Magic: The Gathering • The Brothers' War
No Listings Available
No listings available right now.
Market & Price History
| Condition | Value | Source | Trend | Price Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
$1.43 | Guide Estimate | +11.7% | ||
- $1.43
- Source
- Guide Estimate
- Trend
- +11.7%
- Price Details
30-day Price History
Raw / Ungraded
TCGplayer Market (reference) · Guide Estimate evidence · captured Nov 20, 2026
Description
Painful Quandary, identified as card number 111 in Magic: The Gathering's 2022 Brothers' War expansion, stands as a formidable control piece for players seeking to manage the board state through resource denial. As a rare enchantment with a mana cost of three generic and two black mana, this card requires significant investment to play but offers a potent defensive mechanism that scales effectively in the late game. The card functions by forcing any opponent who casts a spell to pay a steep price: they must discard a card or lose five life. This mechanic creates a difficult choice for adversaries, often disrupting their hand integrity or chipping away at their life total over the course of a match. Designed by artist David Palumbo, the card embodies the thematic tension of the Brothers' War era, reflecting the desperate strategic maneuvers that defined the conflict between the brothers. Collectors appreciate this card not only for its gameplay utility but also for its place within one of Magic's most historically significant sets. The Brothers' War is renowned for its deep lore and intricate card design, making Painful Quandary a desirable addition for enthusiasts of the Black color identity. For collectors, acquiring this card offers a chance to own a piece of the Brothers' War narrative without the need for complex authentication processes typical of memorabilia. It serves as a solid foundation for decks focused on attrition and control, appealing to players who enjoy tactical depth. Whether you are building a competitive deck or expanding your collection of rare cards from this pivotal era, Painful Quandary represents a key intersection of strategic value and historical significance within the Magic: The Gathering canon.
Have one of these to sell?
We'll pre-fill the product details from this catalog entry, so your listing lands on this exact page. Just add photos of your copy, pick its condition, and set your price.
Card Details
The catalog profile below summarizes the card identity, featured subject, and notable collectible traits.
Catalog Profile
The core identity of the card within the set.
Featured Subject
The subject, team, league, and sport context tied to this card.
Featured
Painful Quandary
Game
Magic: The Gathering
TCG Attributes
Rarity, print treatment, and game-specific stats for this card.
Rare
David Palumbo
Card Stock
English
{3}{B}{B}
Enchantment
B
Card Text
Abilities, attacks, oracle text, and flavor text printed on the card.
Whenever an opponent casts a spell, that player loses 5 life unless they discard a card.
In Mishra's desperation to destroy his brother, he allowed Gix to destroy him instead.
Looking for This Item?
No stocked SuperCatch offers are available here. You can search another marketplace; availability and prices may vary.
FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
What does Painful Quandary do in Magic: The Gathering?
Painful Quandary is a rare enchantment that forces opponents to discard a card or lose 5 life whenever they cast a spell. It acts as a powerful deterrent against aggressive strategies and helps control the game's pace.
Who designed the art for Painful Quandary?
The art for Painful Quandary was created by David Palumbo, a well-known illustrator in the Magic: The Gathering community. His work captures the dramatic and dark themes associated with the Brothers' War expansion.
Is Painful Quandary part of a specific set?
Yes, Painful Quandary is card number 111 from The Brothers' War set, released in 2022. It is a rare card within this expansion, which focuses on the legendary conflict between the brothers Urza and Mishra.
Cards Named Painful Quandary
Explore cards with this name across sets and editions. Check each card’s details before choosing a version.
Tap an image to preview it, or a card’s name to open its page.






