The 2022 Magic: The Gathering card Painful Quandary, card number 331 from The Brothers' War expansion. This rare foil enchantment features a bold finish and powerful gameplay mechanics.
Painful Quandary
2022 • Magic: The Gathering • The Brothers' War
No Listings Available
No listings available right now.
Market Price Guide
| Condition | Value | Comps | Source | Price Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Raw / Ungraded | $6.42 | Unknown | Guide Estimate Based on TCGplayer Market (reference) | Source Observation Date Unavailable |
Price HistoryOver the last 30 days, stored prices ranged from $5.67 to $6.42 across 2 capture days. Change between Sep 4, 2026 and Sep 16, 2026: 13.2%. Compares the same source, grade and signed status. Capture days are not completed-sale counts. | ||||
Raw / Ungraded
$6.42- Comps
- Unknown
- Source
Guide Estimate
Based on TCGplayer Market (reference)- Price Date
- Source Observation Date Unavailable
Price HistoryOver the last 30 days, stored prices ranged from $5.67 to $6.42 across 2 capture days. Change between Sep 4, 2026 and Sep 16, 2026: 13.2%. Compares the same source, grade and signed status. Capture days are not completed-sale counts.
Price History
Description
The 2022 Magic: The Gathering card Painful Quandary, card number 331 from The Brothers' War expansion, is a rare enchantment that has become a staple for fans of the game's strategic depth. Printed with a striking foil finish, this card stands out in any collection, offering both aesthetic appeal and functional power within the game's complex ecosystem. The Brothers' War set, identified by the BRO set code, brought a distinct visual and mechanical identity to the trading card game, and this enchantment is a prime example of its design philosophy. As a rare card, Painful Quandary commands attention with its {3}{B}{B} mana cost and five mana value, requiring significant resources to cast but delivering substantial impact. The card's effect is straightforward yet devastating: whenever an opponent casts a spell, they must discard a card or lose 5 life. This mechanic applies to any spell, making it a versatile tool against a wide variety of strategies. The card's black color identity aligns it with decks that focus on disruption and life gain, providing a tactical advantage in competitive play. For collectors, the foil treatment adds a layer of desirability, enhancing the card's visual presence. The artist, David Palumbo, contributed to the set's overall aesthetic, though the specific details of the illustration are best appreciated in person. The Brothers' War expansion itself was a significant release, drawing on the rich lore of the Magic universe and introducing new mechanics that continue to influence the game. Painful Quandary fits seamlessly into this context, offering a powerful option for players who enjoy controlling the board state. Whether you are building a competitive deck or expanding your collection of rare foil cards, Painful Quandary represents a key piece of The Brothers' War. Its combination of rarity, foil finish, and impactful gameplay makes it a valuable addition for any Magic: The Gathering enthusiast. The card's design and mechanics reflect the high standards of the Brothers' War set, ensuring it remains a relevant and sought-after item in the trading card game community.
Have one of these to sell?
We'll pre-fill the product details from this catalog entry, so your listing lands on this exact page. Just add photos of your copy, pick its condition, and set your price.
Card Details
The catalog profile below summarizes the card identity, featured subject, and notable collectible traits.
Catalog Profile
The core identity of the card within the set.
Featured Subject
The subject, team, league, and sport context tied to this card.
Featured
Painful Quandary
Game
Magic: The Gathering
TCG Attributes
Rarity, print treatment, and game-specific stats for this card.
Rare
David Palumbo
Card Stock
English
Foil
{3}{B}{B}
Enchantment
B
Card Text
Abilities, attacks, oracle text, and flavor text printed on the card.
Whenever an opponent casts a spell, that player loses 5 life unless they discard a card.







