The 1991 Fleer #257 Brett Butler sports card is a definitive piece of MLB history, capturing the San Francisco Giants outfielder during a key era of his career.
Guide Estimate: $1.11. Evidence date not available.
Asking Prices: $1.00. Evidence date: Sep 17, 2026.Lowest observed item price: $0.99; shipping and tax excluded.Lowest observed item plus quoted shipping: $1.00, among 21 offers with known shipping; tax excluded.
Asking prices are unsold offers, not completed sales. Repeated observations do not establish additional buyer demand.Supported by the available observations, but not a guaranteed sale price.
Over the last 30 days, stored prices ranged from $1.00 to $1.00 across 2 capture days. Change between Sep 1, 2026 and Sep 17, 2026: 0%. Compares the same source, grade and signed status. Capture days are not completed-sale counts.
$1.00
Source
Asking Prices
Trend
0%
Price Details
Based on eBay Active Listings · 22 observations
Estimate: $1.00, based on Asking Prices.
Guide Estimate: $1.11. Evidence date not available.
Asking Prices: $1.00. Evidence date: Sep 17, 2026.Lowest observed item price: $0.99; shipping and tax excluded.Lowest observed item plus quoted shipping: $1.00, among 21 offers with known shipping; tax excluded.
Asking prices are unsold offers, not completed sales. Repeated observations do not establish additional buyer demand.Supported by the available observations, but not a guaranteed sale price.
Over the last 30 days, stored prices ranged from $1.00 to $1.00 across 2 capture days. Change between Sep 1, 2026 and Sep 17, 2026: 0%. Compares the same source, grade and signed status. Capture days are not completed-sale counts.
Each point is the last stored observation that day for this printing, condition, grader, autograph status and source. Gaps mean no observation; guide estimates and asking prices are not completed sales.
Product Overview
Description
The 1991 Fleer #257 Brett Butler sports card captures the San Francisco Giants outfielder during a pivotal period of his Major League Baseball career. As part of the renowned Fleer brand, this release is recognized by collectors for its distinctive design and high-quality production values that defined early 1990s trading cards. Brett Butler, known for his exceptional speed and contact hitting, wore the Giants uniform during the years this card was printed, making it a relevant piece for enthusiasts of the team's history. Collecting the 1991 Fleer set is a popular pursuit among hobbyists who appreciate the era's aesthetic and the competitive landscape of MLB at the time. This card, numbered 257, serves as a key component for those looking to complete their personal archives of Fleer releases. The product represents a tangible connection to the sport's past, offering a snapshot of Butler's tenure with the Giants before his later moves to other franchises. For investors and serious collectors, the 1991 Fleer Brett Butler card holds a steady place in the market for vintage baseball memorabilia. Its enduring appeal lies in its association with a well-respected manufacturer and a player who was a staple in the National League lineup. Whether you are building a comprehensive collection of Giants players or focusing on the Fleer brand specifically, this card provides a solid foundation. The combination of brand prestige, player relevance, and set completeness makes this a versatile addition to any portfolio.
Last Listing Activity
9/17/26
Seller Action
Have one of these to sell?
We'll pre-fill the product details from this catalog entry, so your listing lands on this exact page. Just add photos of your copy, pick its condition, and set your price.
Product Specs
Card Details
The catalog profile below summarizes the card identity, featured subject, and notable collectible traits.
See how many public collections currently include this card.
0 collectors have this card
SuperCatch Expert Analysis
Market Value Insight
This 1991 Fleer card represents a baseline entry point for Brett Butler collectors, reflecting its status as a common base card from the early 1990s. While it lacks the scarcity to command significant premiums, it serves as an affordable component for completing a set or building a themed collection. The current market positioning indicates it trades at the lower end of the spectrum for Butler memorabilia, accessible to new collectors without substantial financial risk.
Rarity Breakdown
As a standard base card from the 1991 Fleer set, this item does not feature serial numbering, short-print designations, or parallel finishes that typically constrain supply. Its availability is determined by the original print run volume, which was high for base inserts during this era, resulting in widespread distribution. Consequently, the card carries no inherent scarcity mechanics beyond the natural attrition of older paper goods over time.
Investment Outlook
The investment potential for this specific card is limited due to the absence of rookie-year status or unique grading advantages that drive collector demand. While Fleer maintains a nostalgic appeal for 1990s baseball enthusiasts, this particular base card is unlikely to appreciate significantly given its abundance. Collectors may acquire it for portfolio diversity or set completion rather than as a primary vehicle for capital growth.
