The 1990 Topps Todd Stottlemyre #591 sports trading card features the Toronto Blue Jays pitcher. A vintage piece of baseball history from the iconic 1990 Topps set.
Estimated delivery October 1, 2026 - October 3, 2026
30-day Returns
Market & Price History
Prices Captured Sep 3, 2026 Unless Another Date Is Shown
Condition
Value
Source
Trend
Price Details
$1.28
Asking Prices
-1.5%
Based on eBay Active Listings · 23 observations
Estimate: $1.28, based on Asking Prices.
Asking Prices: $1.28. Evidence date: Sep 21, 2026.Lowest observed item price: $0.99; shipping and tax excluded.Lowest observed item plus quoted shipping: $0.99, among 26 offers with known shipping; tax excluded.
Asking prices are unsold offers, not completed sales. Repeated observations do not establish additional buyer demand.Supported by the available observations, but not a guaranteed sale price.
Over the last 30 days, stored prices ranged from $1.28 to $1.30 across 2 capture days. Change between Sep 3, 2026 and Sep 21, 2026: -1.5%. Compares the same source, grade and signed status. Capture days are not completed-sale counts.
$1.25As of 9/3/2026
Guide Estimate
Based on Aggregated Price GuideGuide grade mapping; not verified grader-specific sales
Estimate: $1.25, based on Guide Estimate.
Source date not availableSupported by the available observations, but not a guaranteed sale price.
$49.95As of 9/3/2026
Guide Estimate
Based on Aggregated Price GuideGuide grade mapping; not verified grader-specific sales
Estimate: $49.95, based on Guide Estimate.
Source date not availableThis estimate is older and may not reflect today's market.
$55.00As of 9/3/2026
Guide Estimate
Based on Aggregated Price GuideGuide grade mapping; not verified grader-specific sales
Estimate: $55.00, based on Guide Estimate.
Source date not availableThis estimate is older and may not reflect today's market.
$1.28
Source
Asking Prices
Trend
-1.5%
Price Details
Based on eBay Active Listings · 23 observations
Estimate: $1.28, based on Asking Prices.
Asking Prices: $1.28. Evidence date: Sep 21, 2026.Lowest observed item price: $0.99; shipping and tax excluded.Lowest observed item plus quoted shipping: $0.99, among 26 offers with known shipping; tax excluded.
Asking prices are unsold offers, not completed sales. Repeated observations do not establish additional buyer demand.Supported by the available observations, but not a guaranteed sale price.
Over the last 30 days, stored prices ranged from $1.28 to $1.30 across 2 capture days. Change between Sep 3, 2026 and Sep 21, 2026: -1.5%. Compares the same source, grade and signed status. Capture days are not completed-sale counts.
$1.25As of 9/3/2026
Source
Guide Estimate
Trend
Price Details
Based on Aggregated Price GuideGuide grade mapping; not verified grader-specific sales
Estimate: $1.25, based on Guide Estimate.
Source date not availableSupported by the available observations, but not a guaranteed sale price.
$49.95As of 9/3/2026
Source
Guide Estimate
Trend
Price Details
Based on Aggregated Price GuideGuide grade mapping; not verified grader-specific sales
Estimate: $49.95, based on Guide Estimate.
Source date not availableThis estimate is older and may not reflect today's market.
$55.00As of 9/3/2026
Source
Guide Estimate
Trend
Price Details
Based on Aggregated Price GuideGuide grade mapping; not verified grader-specific sales
Estimate: $55.00, based on Guide Estimate.
Source date not availableThis estimate is older and may not reflect today's market.
Below grade 10 the guide publishes one estimate across all graders, so these rows are not PSA, BGS, CGC or SGC prices, and a low slabbed grade can sit below a clean raw copy. Grade 10 is estimated per grader.
Each point is the last stored observation that day for this printing, condition, grader, autograph status and source. Gaps mean no observation; guide estimates and asking prices are not completed sales.
Product Overview
Description
The 1990 Topps Todd Stottlemyre #591 represents a specific moment in baseball card collecting history. As a member of the Toronto Blue Jays roster during the 1990 season, Stottlemyre is featured on this standard base card, numbered 591 within the expansive Topps checklist. For collectors focusing on the Toronto Blue Jays, this card serves as a tangible link to the team's roster during a pivotal era. Stottlemyre's presence on the team during this time adds historical context to the card, making it relevant for those tracking player rosters and team compositions from the decade. The card's straightforward design reflects the manufacturing style of the time, prioritizing clear imagery and essential player information. Vintage baseball cards from this period have established a strong secondary market, driven by nostalgia and the desire to complete specific team sets or era-based collections. The 1990 Topps release offers a diverse array of cards, allowing collectors to target individual players like Stottlemyre or build out comprehensive sets. Whether you are an investor looking at historical trends or a hobbyist building a personal library, this card provides a concrete entry point into the 1990s baseball card market. By focusing on catalog-level details, we ensure that collectors can identify the exact product they seek. This Todd Stottlemyre card is a fundamental component for anyone interested in the Toronto Blue Jays' history or the broader landscape of 1990s baseball trading cards. Its inclusion in the 1990 Topps series guarantees its place in the conversation about classic sports collectibles. ## Is the 1990 Topps Todd Stottlemyre #591 considered a rookie card? No, this card is not a rookie card. Todd Stottlemyre made his Major League debut earlier, and this #591 card was released in 1990, several years into his career. Rookie cards are typically the first officially issued cards featuring a player, which this release is not. ## What team does Todd Stottlemyre play for on this 1990 Topps card? On the 1990 Topps #591 card, Todd Stottlemyre is listed as a member of the Toronto Blue Jays. This reflects his team affiliation during the 1990 MLB season, which is the primary context for this card release. ## How does the 1990 Topps set differ from other baseball card sets? The 1990 Topps set is distinguished by its specific design elements and checklist composition typical of that year's production. It is part of the long-running Topps series, which is the dominant brand in the baseball card hobby, making its 1990 release a standard reference point for collectors of that decade.
Last Listing Activity
9/19/26
Seller Action
Have one of these to sell?
We'll pre-fill the product details from this catalog entry, so your listing lands on this exact page. Just add photos of your copy, pick its condition, and set your price.
Product Specs
Card Details
The catalog profile below summarizes the card identity, featured subject, and notable collectible traits.
Estimated delivery October 1, 2026 - October 3, 2026
Collector Ownership
Owned by Collectors
See how many public collections currently include this card.
0 collectors have this card
SuperCatch Expert Analysis
Market Value Insight
This 1990 Topps Todd Stottlemyre card represents a standard base-level asset, trading at a modest entry point relative to premium parallels or autographed variants. While the player's tenure with the Toronto Blue Jays provides historical context, the absence of special attributes keeps this item in a lower price tier compared to his more sought-after rookie or insert cards. Current market activity suggests a stable but low-demand environment typical of common base cards from this era.
Rarity Breakdown
As a standard base card without serial numbering, short-print designation, or parallel foil treatments, this item carries no inherent supply constraints beyond general production volume. The lack of unique identifiers means it is one of many identical copies in circulation, resulting in high availability and minimal scarcity value. Collectors typically view this type of card as a filler item rather than a rare collectible.
Investment Outlook
Given its status as a common base card from 1990, the investment potential is limited by the sheer volume of existing copies and the lack of special features. Demand is primarily driven by basic set completion needs rather than speculative growth or rarity appreciation. Investors seeking significant returns should look toward graded examples or special inserts, as this raw base card lacks the mechanics to command a premium.
